Joint american-russian project with participation of:
American University in MoscowKontinent USARussia House
American-Russian relations: from confrontation to alliance
Last updated: 4 February 2012

::Face of the day

Spies, Honey Traps, U.S. ­ Russian Reset, and the sad state of the Russian opposition

Spies, Honey Traps, U.S. ­ Russian Reset, and the sad state of the Russian opposition
July 11, 2010
Edward LOZANSKY, President, American University in Moscow

It would be naive to assume that with the end of the Cold War all intelligence activities might terminate. For one thing, there is still a deep mistrust on both sides of the East-West divide, a legacy of the past. For another, intelligence services all over the world have to somehow justify their impressive budgets. As a matter of fact, intelligence activities go on not only on the territories of potential adversaries but even on friendly ones. The effectiveness of these activities nowadays is pretty questionable since much of the information sought by the agents is available on the Internet. Nevertheless, whether we like it or not, the attempts by Russia or United States to plant the moles into each others government and other important structures will continue for any foreseeable future. Besides, huge monies are being allotted for the job, and it will go on ­ if only to justify the expense. These 11 men and women are hardly innocent of the charges made against them, but the timing of their arrest is very curious. Many in the media and in political circles have expressed the view that some powerful folks in Washington do not like the fast pace of U.S. ­ Russia rapprochement in the last few months. We are told that the FBI investigation has gone on for a decade; so far no harm has been done to US interests; so why launch the spy scandal precisely at this moment? Couldn’t the FBI wait a few more weeks, months or years ­ until at least one member of the ring carried out some authentic act of espionage?

Apparently the White House and the Kremlin have decided, thank God, that this unfortunate case should not jeopardize the «reset» process. Both sides are refraining from inflammatory rhetoric. Solid, friendly U.S. — Russia relations are too important to allow spies, their handlers and «reset» opponents to ruin all the good work that has been done by the Obama and Medvedev administrations.

It must be said in all fairness that opponents of friendly U.S. ­ Russian relations exist not only in Washington but in Moscow as well. Amazingly, they are to be found both among diehard Communists or other anti-Western elements and, ironically, even among leaders of the so-called democratic opposition in Russia. Their message to the West is this: it is immoral to deal with the current Kremlin regime. If you listen to Messrs. Kasparov, Illarionov, Limonov & Co., the best way for the West to deal with Russia is to isolate it, expel it from the G-8, and go on insisting that it was Russia that invaded Georgia in August 2008 and, to cap it all, had a hand in downing the Polish presidential plane. All those who disagree with their position and advocate better U.S. ­ Russian relations to meet the common global challenges are called at best naïve or opportunistic, or at worst Russian agents of influence.

If you believe Russia’s free democratic media like the Ekho Moskvy radio station or the Novaya Gazeta newspaper, one must extend the list of those bad guys from 11 to at least 13. The names are mentioned out loud: Number 12 is yours truly, and number 13, Dmitry Simes, head of the Nixon Center. I cannot speak for Dmitry, I am sure he can handle this on his own. As for myself, reporter Julia Latynina who works for both these media outlets completely blows my cover or «legend» which has served me so well for the last 34 years.

According to her, back in 1976 the KGB developed a brilliant plan that would make James Bond look like a novice in a kindergarten. They provided me with bait (technically known as a «honey trap») in the form of a beautiful high school graduate who happened to be the daughter of a Soviet Marshal (that would be a 5-star general in the American military hierarchy). According to the KGB plan, we were supposed to get married and produce a child fast. Then the KGB would separate us and kick me out of the country all the way to America keeping wife and child as hostages. After that we were supposed to start a campaign to be reunited, thus building up my anti-Soviet reputation and eventually help me penetrate the highest political circles of the United States aiming to report back what was on their minds. Part of the campaign was some brilliant KGB moves, like my continuous and loud Soviet bashing and my wife’s hunger strike, to make us more believable. The KGB apparently knew, as far back as 1976, that the Soviet Union was doomed so it did some really long-term planning. The most important part of our assignment had to be carried out when communism and the USSR collapsed: we came in out of the cold to start our real work, working for the improvement of U.S. — Russian relations. As I mentioned, all this was said repeatedly by Yulia Latynina on Ekho Moskvy and printed in Novaya Gazeta, two icons of pro-Western democratic media outlets, real darlings of the West, and posted on Johnson Russia List in English. By the way, it is the same Latynina who got the State Department Freedom Award from the previous administration.

I know well both Alexei Venediktov, chief editor of Ekho Moskvy, and Dmitry Muratov, chief editor of Novaya Gazeta, and I asked them to permit me to reply to Latynina’s slander campaign in their media outlets. Dmitry Muratov did that but from the Echo of Moscow so far, dead silence. This sort of freedom of the press is a bit one-sided, don’t you think?

However, I did get one pleasant consolation moment when another prominent Russian human rights advocate with tons of U.S. grants Ludmila Alexeyeva now names no one else but Echo chief Alexei Venediktov to be FSB (KGB successor) agent for expressing different from hers opinion on Moscow demonstrations.

Here is the sad state of the Russian democratic opposition these days. Now you understand why Medvedev’s and Putin’s popularity is so high. It is not difficult to compete with these so-called democrats who cannot agree among themselves and who even join forces with communists and national Bolsheviks. It appears that the only thing that unites them is their hatred for the Kremlin. However, this is hardly enough to overcome the single digit ratings in the polls.

Isn’t it a right time for America to evaluate the cost effectiveness and results of the democracy promotion crusade in the post-Soviet space, including color revolutions? Investing these funds in U.S. ­ Russia high tech cooperation like Skolkovo project would be a much smarter policy. That is, of course, if we want Russia to be on our side. On the other hand, according to Latynina the idea of U.S. ­ Russia alliance belongs to KGB, so there is some food for thought.

Joel Brinkley

Listening to Vladimir Putin trying to salvage his career as his base of support seems to be crumbling around him, the Russian prime minister sounds more and more like all of those Arab dictators just before their own people turned on them in angry revolt.

'Stability is something that can only be achieved through hard work, by being open to change and ready for long-overdue, well-planned and well-calculated reforms,' Putin declared in an online campaign essay this month.

 So said Syrian President Bashar Assad almost exactly a year ago, just before his own country dissolved into protest, chaos and slaughter.
Joel Brinkley

Listening to Vladimir Putin trying to salvage his career as his base of support seems to be crumbling around him, the Russian prime minister sounds more and more like all of those Arab dictators just before their own people turned on them in angry revolt.

'Stability is something that can only be achieved through hard work, by being open to change and ready for long-overdue, well-planned and well-calculated reforms,' Putin declared in an online campaign essay this month.

 So said Syrian President Bashar Assad almost exactly a year ago, just before his own country dissolved into protest, chaos and slaughter.
Keyur Patel
High quality global journalism requires investment. Please share this article with others using the link below, do not cut & paste the article. See our Ts&Cs and Copyright Policy for more detail. Russia released a preliminary estimate for 2011 GDP growth on Tuesday - and at 4.3 per cent, it looks pretty healthy. The figure crept ahead of analyst expectations, buoyed by a strong recovery in consumer demand over the year, while 2010 growth was revised upwards, also to 4.3 per cent. Renaissance Capital was cautiously bullish, calling the forecast 'reason for a (modest) celebration'.
© "America-Russia.net". American-Russian alliance. All Rights Reserved.
Editorial Office in USA: 1800 Connecticut Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20009; Tel. 202-364-0200; Fax 240-554-1650; e-mail: russia@russiahouse.org
Site supported by: Kontinent USA and American University in Moscow ,2011
Rambler's Top100 Рейтинг@Mail.ru